Why Nonprofits Should Shape Funding Priorities, Not Follow Them
The end of the year is the busiest season for individual giving, and many nonprofit leaders are fine-tuning their appeals right now. At the same time, nonprofits are managing funding cuts and other constraints, especially from reduced federal funding.
When money is tight, understandably, funders’ rules and priorities guide what an organization does. Those constraints are real, and they belong in your planning. Nevertheless, your organization’s strategic direction should run the other way: nonprofits identify what their communities need, establish their priorities, and then educate funders about where their support can make the biggest difference. Strategy comes first, and fund development follows.
What it looks like in practice
As one of Belinda’s mentors told her as she was fundraising for her nonprofit, “Belinda, you need money, but you don’t need any one particular funder’s money.”
Here are three examples when organizations led with their values, and the funding followed:
From unfunded to one of the largest programs. When Belinda was an executive director, her organization ran a homelessness prevention program that was in high demand, badly needed, and the only one of its kind in the Bay Area. Yet it had no dedicated funding. Nevertheless, because the need was clear, the organization took a calculated financial risk and used unrestricted dollars to sustain and deepen the program, including convening a year-long citywide task force that developed policy recommendations. The task force presented its findings to the city, helping policymakers and city leaders understand the need. The organization also developed events and educational materials on the issue that generated revenue while advancing its educational impact. By the time Belinda left the organization, the city was funding the program, which supplemented earned income from events and educational materials, leading it to become one of the organization’s largest funded programs.
Serving the communities that need you, not just the ones funders cover. At a recent retreat we facilitated, in response to concerns about funder priorities, a board member pointed out that the organization’s mission called for serving clients in several languages for which there is community need, even if current funding covers programming and staffing only in some languages. The board agreed that community needs, not the limitations of existing funding, should determine whom the organization serves. To pay for services without current funding, they decided they’d fundraise, educating funders about the need and why it matters.
Standing by your values can grow support. In 2015, Girl Scouts of Western Washington returned a $100,000 gift after the donor asked that none of it support transgender girls. The organization then asked the public to replace the funding, and in about two days, more than 5,000 people gave over $250,000, two and a half times the amount it had turned down. Not every decision to stand by your values will go viral, but clarity about who you are, what you stand for, and whom you serve will help educate your community, including funders, and attract supporters who share your commitments and will stay with you.
Strategic Leadership Means Knowing When to Say No
Being mission-centered doesn’t mean pursuing every worthy opportunity or ignoring financial realities. It means making intentional choices about where to invest your resources and what you can realistically accomplish.
The availability of funding doesn’t necessarily make something a priority, just as the absence of funding doesn’t make something less important.
Sometimes the most strategic decision is to decline funding that would pull your organization away from its mission. Other times, it’s to invest in an important need before a funder recognizes its value. Both require clarity about your mission, confidence in your strategy, and the discipline to make difficult choices.
Questions for your next board or leadership meeting
As you’re planning for your nonprofit, consider these questions:
Where are we meeting a significant community need without dedicated funding? How can we make the case for investing in this work to major donors, funders, and policymakers?
What unrestricted revenue do we have available to invest in priorities that fall within our mission? How can we grow that revenue through individual giving?
Have we accepted any funding conditions that pull us away from our mission? What would it take to reconsider them?
The bottom line
You, together with the clients and communities you serve, are the experts on what’s needed. Use that expertise to educate donors, funders, and community leaders so they understand the needs you are seeing and where their support can make the biggest difference. Funding should follow your mission, not set it.